Hey everyone, Josh here from Indie Creator Hub, and I just wrapped up a stream where we dove deep into the current state of Twitter alternatives. Honestly? After spending real time on Threads, Mastodon, and Blue Sky, I'm starting to think the problem isn't finding the perfect Twitter replacement. The problem is that we're all still thinking like Twitter users.
Threads: The Fire Hose Nobody Asked For
So Threads exploded out of the gate, hit 100 million users in the first few days, then lost about 80% of them just as fast. And look, I was there for that initial chaos. It wasn't just a fire hose of content, it was like standing under Niagara Falls getting pelted with brand posts and random accounts you'd never heard of.
The first day was completely insane. I spent more time hitting mute and block than actually engaging with anything meaningful. Every brand that had fled Twitter just dumped their entire posting strategy onto Threads without thinking about whether it made sense.
But here's the thing that actually matters. Once that initial flood calmed down and they added the Following feed, Threads became surprisingly usable. Not perfect, but usable. The problem is they're still mobile-only with no desktop access, and honestly, that's killing adoption among creators who actually want to engage with their communities instead of just scrolling on their phones.
The Instagram account linking situation is still a mess too. You can't delete your Threads account without nuking your Instagram, which means people are stuck in this weird limbo where they're afraid to fully commit because they might lose years of Instagram content if they want to bail.
Mastodon: Great Concept, Terrible Onboarding
Then there's Mastodon, which has all the right ideas and the worst possible execution for mainstream adoption. The decentralized instance model is brilliant in theory. No single point of failure, no billionaire can buy the whole thing and run it into the ground, communities can actually control their own spaces.
But telling someone to "just pick an instance" is like handing them a hammer and saying "go build a house." It's not that people are stupid, it's that we've trained them for decades to expect centralized platforms where you sign up once and you're done.
The growing pains are real too. Every time Twitter does something particularly stupid and drives another wave of users to Mastodon, instances crash because they're run by volunteers with their own money, not billion-dollar server farms. And when an instance admin gets burned out from harassment and shuts down, thousands of users lose their communities overnight.
That said, when Mastodon works, it really works. No algorithm pushing engagement bait, no ads, just chronological feeds of people and topics you actually chose to follow. It's what social media felt like before it became an attention extraction machine.
Blue Sky: The Exclusive Club That's Missing the Point
Blue Sky is Jack Dorsey's attempt to rebuild Twitter with federation, but they're doing it through invite-only access that's creating artificial scarcity. It's like the early Gmail invitation system, except Gmail had Google's infrastructure behind it and a clear value proposition.
The AT Protocol they built instead of using ActivityPub is interesting from a technical standpoint, but it fragments the ecosystem. Why build a new wheel when ActivityPub already works and connects to the wider Fediverse?
More concerning is their handling of moderation issues. When marginalized communities are saying the platform isn't responding fast enough to harassment, and your response is to stay invite-only and work on features, you're missing the entire point of why people left Twitter in the first place.
The slow growth strategy might work for a social network launching in 2010, but in 2023, if you can't catch the fire when Twitter hands you multiple opportunities on a silver platter, you're probably not going to catch it at all.
The Pattern Nobody Wants to Acknowledge
Here's what using all three platforms taught me. We're not just looking for Twitter alternatives, we're looking for communities that don't treat us like content factories. But most of us are still approaching these platforms with Twitter habits, expecting the same dopamine hit from the same engagement patterns.
Threads gives you the familiar experience but keeps you locked into Meta's ecosystem. Mastodon gives you control but demands you learn new concepts. Blue Sky promises federation while keeping most people locked out entirely.
None of them are wrong, exactly. But none of them are solving the fundamental problem either.
What This Means for Independent Creators
The diversity isn't accidental. It's what happens when people get tired of being at the mercy of corporate algorithm changes and start building alternatives. But the uncomfortable truth is that platform choice only matters if you're willing to actually build community instead of just broadcasting into the void.
I'm on all three platforms, and you know what works best? Actually engaging with people instead of trying to game whatever algorithm might or might not exist. Shocking concept, right?
The future isn't about finding the one perfect Twitter replacement. It's about having enough viable alternatives that creators can make choices based on what actually serves their communities instead of just accepting whatever the algorithm decides this week.
Moving Forward
Look, I don't know which of these platforms will still be around in five years. What matters is whether they're pushing the ecosystem toward treating creators and users like humans instead of engagement metrics.
Twitter's implosion created space for experimentation. Some of these experiments will fail, others will evolve into something better than what we lost. But only if we're willing to actually try them instead of just complaining that they're not exactly like Twitter used to be.
Your turn. What would it take for you to actually commit to building community on an alternative platform? Because the future of social media depends not just on the platforms that get built, but on the communities willing to make them work.
Let me know in the comments or hit me up on whatever platform you actually check regularly. And if this resonated with you, become a creator supporter at indiecreator.community.
Until next time, keep creating independently.
JoshB
The Independent Creator
Recommended Comments