Hey everyone, Josh here from Indie Creator Space, and uh, so I've been thinking a lot lately about community platforms after diving deep into what actually works for content creators. Like, should you even bother with your own forum? Is Discord really the answer everyone thinks it is? And how do you avoid getting locked into someone else's walled garden?
And honestly? After years of running communities on different platforms, making mistakes, watching services disappear, I figured it was time to break down the real talk about building communities that last.
The Thing About Communities Nobody Wants to Admit
So here's the deal, and I'm just gonna be real with you because that's what we do here. Most creators jump straight to Discord because it's easy, familiar, and free. But there's a fundamental problem nobody talks about.
You don't actually own your Discord community. You're basically subletting space in someone else's building. Discord changes their rules? Your community could disappear overnight. All your history, all your member connections - gone.
And here's the kicker - all that knowledge and discussion happening in your Discord server? It's locked behind a wall. Nobody outside your server can find it through Google. It's not searchable, not discoverable, just... trapped.
Before Discord dominated everything, we had forums. And honestly? Forums solved a lot of problems we've forgotten about.
Why Forums Still Make Sense (Even In 2023)
Look, I know forums feel old-school, but hear me out. Forums give you something Discord never will - actual ownership of your community.
With a forum, you control the data. You can export member lists for newsletters. You can move hosting if needed. And most importantly, your content is searchable. When someone googles a problem you've discussed, they can actually find your forum.
I've used Xenforo for years across different projects, and their complete package keeps getting better. Yeah, it's $160 upfront plus annual support costs, but think about what you're getting - a platform that won't disappear because some VC-backed company changes strategy.
Their cloud hosting starts at $54/month if you don't want to deal with server management. That includes backups, security, the whole thing. Compare that to paying Discord Nitro for basic features that should be free.
There's also Invision Community (formerly IPB) with similar capabilities but different pricing tiers. Both are solid choices if you're serious about community building.
The Discord Reality Check
Don't get me wrong - Discord isn't evil. It revolutionized online communities by making voice chat accessible and creating that seamless chat experience we all got used to.
But here's what bothers me about Discord evangelism. Everyone acts like Discord is the only option, but they're ignoring some massive downsides.
First, information decay. In active Discord servers, conversations disappear into chat history. Someone asks a great question, gets a detailed answer, then it's buried under hours of random chat. That knowledge is effectively lost.
Second, the walled garden problem I mentioned. Your Discord server might as well not exist for anyone who isn't already a member. Zero discoverability.
Third, platform dependency. Discord's algorithm changes, pricing shifts, feature removals - you have zero control over any of it.
Guilded: The Alternative Nobody Talks About
Speaking of alternatives, let's talk about Guilded for a minute. It's basically Discord with features that should have been standard from day one.
Animated emotes? Free. High-quality voice chat? Built-in. Forums, calendars, scheduling tools? All included without needing third-party bots cluttering up your member list.
The grouping system alone makes Guilded worth considering. You can organize different sections of your community - like separate areas for different games or topics - and let people opt into only what interests them.
But here's the problem with Guilded: getting people to move. Discord has that mind-share lock. People hear "Discord alternative" and immediately dismiss it as a knockoff. Which is frustrating because Guilded actually innovated features Discord later copied.
Matrix: For the Privacy-Focused
If you're more security-conscious, there's Matrix with Element as the interface. It's open source, privacy-focused, with end-to-end encryption for sensitive discussions.
The downside? It's missing some quality-of-life features, and again, you're dealing with the walled garden problem. Plus, convincing people to join yet another platform when they're already Discord-comfortable is an uphill battle.
What You Actually Need (Spoiler: It Depends)
Look, there's no perfect solution. Each platform serves different needs.
If you want quick community setup with minimal hassle, Discord works. Just understand you're building on rented land.
If you want long-term ownership and searchable content, forums are still the way to go. Yeah, it's more work upfront, but you're building something that lasts.
If you want Discord-style features without the limitations, Guilded is worth exploring. The learning curve is minimal if you're already familiar with Discord.
If privacy and open source matter to your community, Matrix fits that niche.
The Sustainability Question
But here's what I think about most when choosing platforms, and maybe this sounds obvious but stick with me. What happens to your community when the platform changes?
We've seen this before. Reddit's API apocalypse. Twitter becoming... whatever it is now. Google killing projects left and right. Facebook changing algorithms that destroy page reach.
Building on someone else's platform always carries risk. The question is whether the convenience outweighs the potential for disruption.
Starting Smart: Think Long-Term
Here's what I'd recommend, and this is based on watching communities rise and fall over the years. Start with your goals, not the platform.
Are you building a quick fan community around your content? Discord might be fine.
Are you creating a knowledge base for your niche? Forums make more sense.
Do you need real-time collaboration with persistent knowledge? Maybe a hybrid approach.
The most successful creators I know don't rely on single platforms. They use email lists for direct communication, websites for searchable content, and chat platforms for real-time interaction.
What Actually Matters
Look, I don't know which platforms will succeed or which communities will thrive in five years. That's not really the point.
What matters is building something sustainable that serves your audience instead of just following whatever's trendy. Whether that's forums, Discord servers, or some format that doesn't exist yet.
The barriers are lower than ever, the tools keep getting better, and there's room for different approaches to coexist.
Your Turn
So here's what I want to know - what's your community platform experience been like? Are you stuck in Discord because that's where everyone expects you to be? Or have you found success with alternatives?
Because honestly, the best community platform is the one that serves your specific needs, not the one everyone else is using.
Check out our community at https://indiecreator.community if you want to see forums in action. We've got both a website community and a Discord server, because sometimes hybrid approaches just make sense.
If this helped clarify the community platform landscape, let me know in the comments. And if you made it this far through all my rambling about community platforms, thanks for sticking with me.
Until next time, later taters.
---
Links mentioned in this post: Xenforo, Invision Community, Guilded, Matrix/Element
The Independent Creator
Recommended Comments